Ninth Circuit BAP: Lenders Can Validate Foreclosure Sales Held After Last-Minute Involuntary Petitions | By: Shantal Malmed
Ninth Circuit BAP: Lenders Can Validate Foreclosure Sales Held After Last-Minute Involuntary Petitions | By: Shantal Malmed

In its memorandum decision of October 7, 2026 (In re Duplex at Sleepy Hollow, LLC, BAP No. CC-25-1256-NMG), the Bankruptcy Appellate Panel of the Ninth Circuit (BAP) affirmed a Central District of California order retroactively annulling the automatic stay to validate nine nonjudicial foreclosure sales. The sales went forward minutes after insiders filed involuntary chapter 11 petitions that neither the lender nor the foreclosure trustee knew about. The decision is unpublished and not precedential, but it is a useful guide for secured lenders to protect a foreclosure sale from an eleventh-hour bankruptcy filing. It also shows how courts weigh a would-be bidder’s attempt to unwind a lender’s credit-bid sales.

Background: void acts vs. retroactive annulment

  • Void acts: Actions taken in violation of the automatic stay are void (Schwartz v. United States (In re Schwartz), 954 F.2d 569 (9th Cir. 1992)). A foreclosure sale conducted after a petition is filed, even an involuntary one the foreclosing party knows nothing about, is an act to enforce a lien against property of the estate.
  • Retroactive annulment: Section 362(d) nonetheless lets the bankruptcy court annul the stay, which retroactively validates acts that otherwise violated it. The Ninth Circuit balances the equities case by case, looking chiefly at whether the creditor knew of the petition, and whether the debtor acted inequitably or the creditor would be prejudiced (Nat’l Env’t Waste Corp. v. City of Riverside, 129 F.3d 1052 (9th Cir. 1997)). The BAP’s twelve Fjeldsted factors guide that balancing (Fjeldsted v. Lien (In re Fjeldsted), 293 B.R. 12 (9th Cir. BAP 2003)). The BAP has also held that Roman Catholic Archdiocese of San Juan v. Acevedo Feliciano, 589 U.S. 57 (2020), does not bar retroactive stay relief (Merriman v. Fattorini (In re Merriman), 616 B.R. 381 (9th Cir. BAP 2020)).

Facts of the case

Ten related single asset real estate entities owned properties located in Laguna Beach, California, with an estimated value of about $95 million. Enterprise Bank and Trust (Enterprise) held first deeds of trust securing approximately $80 million. After the borrowers defaulted and Enterprise recorded notices of default in February 2025, the borrowers and twelve affiliates filed chapter 11 bankruptcy petitions in Delaware. The Delaware court granted Enterprise unopposed stay relief in July 2025 and dismissed the cases in August.

Enterprise returned to California state court, which appointed a receiver over the properties in October 2025. According to the receiver, one of the two feuding investors behind the borrowers and his related entities kept interfering with management after the appointment. Trustee’s sales were noticed for 3:00 p.m. on October 15, 2025.

Between 2:28 and 3:02 p.m. that day, involuntary chapter 11 petitions were filed against all ten borrowers in the Central District of California. No one informed Enterprise or the foreclosure trustee that the involuntary petitions had been filed. The sales went forward between 3:13 and 3:52 p.m. Enterprise credit bid and acquired title to nine properties. A third party bought the tenth property, but that sale was rescinded after the filings came to light. Notice of the petitions reached the trustee at about 4:10 p.m.

Enterprise moved promptly for stay relief and retroactive annulment. A prospective bidder, S.E. Amster (Amster), opposed annulment only. Amster argued that all ten sales should be re-noticed because the petitions had chilled the bidding. Before the sales, his title agent had told him that a petition was on file against the owner of the property he wanted most – 683 Sleepy Hollow Lane. He chose not to bid and arrived at the auction minutes after that property was sold. Judge Clarkson annulled the stay as to the nine credit-bid properties and found the petitions were filed in bad faith. He also ordered the petitioning creditors to post a $1 million bond. They did not post it, and the involuntary cases were dismissed.

Decision of the Bankruptcy Appellate Panel

The BAP (Niemann, Marum, and Gan, JJ.) affirmed. It resolved two jurisdictional questions first and then upheld the annulment on the merits:

  • The appeal was not moot. Dismissal of the involuntary cases did not undo the annulment or its validation of the nine sales. Therefore, effective relief was still possible.
  • The bidder had standing. The BAP rejected Enterprise’s characterization of Amster as merely a failed bidder. He had funds on hand, was at the auction minutes after his target property was sold, and changed his conduct in reliance on the stay. That was enough to make him directly and adversely affected in a pecuniary sense.
  • The correct legal standard was applied. Any chilling effect on competitive bidding under California foreclosure law is something to weigh when balancing the equities. It is not a separate test for annulment.
  • The equities are not weighed from the bidder’s perspective alone. Fjeldsted does consider prejudice to third parties, including bona fide purchasers, but a prospective bidder who never placed a bid is far from a bona fide purchaser. More importantly, Enterprise’s motion sought relief against the debtors’ property. Thus, the court properly weighed the debtors’ conduct and the full history of the case, not just what happened at the auction. The same facts that showed the involuntary petitions were filed in bad faith, and that gave Enterprise cause for stay relief under § 362(d)(1), also weighed in favor of annulment.
  • The findings were well supported. Neither Enterprise nor the trustee knew of the petitions when the sales were held, the petitions were filed in bad faith, and Enterprise moved for relief within approximately one month. On prejudice, the bankruptcy court emphasized that Enterprise had already obtained stay relief in the borrowers’ earlier Delaware cases, and after those cases were dismissed, went forward with the foreclosures in reliance on those orders. Forcing Enterprise to re-notice and conduct nine sales would penalize a lender that followed prior court authority, while interest kept accruing and the properties remained exposed to the interference the receiver had described.
  • Treating the tenth property differently was not inconsistent. Amster argued that the court could not annul the stay as to nine properties while refusing to do so for the tenth in the same order. The BAP disagreed because the facts were different. The tenth property was the only one sold to a third-party bidder. When that bidder learned of the bankruptcy filings, it demanded either its deed or its money back. In response, the trustee rescinded the sale and returned the funds before Enterprise’s motion was heard. There was no completed sale left to validate. That bidder also waited several months to seek annulment on its own, and the bankruptcy court’s denial of that request is the subject of a separate appeal.

In a footnote, the BAP turned Amster’s own conduct against him. He learned of a filing from his title agent before the auction, yet he did not tell the trustee and did not bid. Had he alerted the trustee, the sales would not have gone forward, and he would have obtained exactly what he asked for on appeal: re-noticed sales. The BAP acknowledged that he had no duty to do either. But it held that his silence weighed substantially against any prejudice he claimed, particularly because a sophisticated foreclosure investor would have known the court could later annul the stay retroactively.

Practical implications

The BAP’s reasoning is consistent with how Ninth Circuit courts have long treated serial and bad-faith filings: the automatic stay protects bankruptcy estates, not litigation tactics. Although the decision is unpublished, it may be cited for its persuasive value, and it offers secured lenders four practical lessons:

  1. Firstly, move quickly and build the record before the filing comes. Enterprise was well positioned because it already had stay-relief orders from the Delaware cases, a court-appointed receiver in place, and documented interference by one of the borrowers’ principals. It also filed its motion within approximately one month of the sales and asked for all of the available relief at once: prospective relief under § 362(d)(1), in rem relief under § 362(d)(4), and retroactive annulment. In rem relief is especially valuable against serial filers because, once recorded, it can bind later bankruptcy cases affecting the same property for two years.
  2. Secondly, consider asking the court to require a bond. Under § 303(e), the court may require petitioning creditors to post a bond to cover the alleged debtor’s costs and damages if an involuntary petition is dismissed. Here, the court ordered the petitioning creditors to post a $1 million bond. That requirement tested whether they were willing to stand behind their petitions with real money. They were not: they never posted the bond, and all ten cases were dismissed. For a lender facing insider involuntary bankruptcies filed to buy time, a bond request can end the cases far faster than litigating the merits of the petitions.
  3. Thirdly, a state court receivership strengthens a lender’s hand. The receiver’s declaration gave the bankruptcy court firsthand, neutral evidence that the borrower-side parties kept interfering with the properties after the appointment, and that evidence fed directly into the court’s prejudice analysis. Lenders should ask their receivers to document interference, diverted rents, and similar conduct as it happens, because that record may later decide whether a foreclosure stands.
  4. Finally, plan for a filing that surfaces at or just after the sale. The nine credit-bid sales were validated. The one third-party sale was not, because the trustee had already rescinded it before the hearing. Lenders should instruct their foreclosure trustees to check the docket immediately before commencing each sale, and to consult counsel before rescinding a completed sale or returning funds. The decision also offers some comfort: a bidder who knows about a filing and stays silent will have a hard time later claiming that annulment hurt him.

This publication is published by the law firm of Ervin Cohen & Jessup LLP. The publication is intended to present an overview of current legal trends; no article should be construed as representing advice on specific, individual legal matters. Articles may be reprinted with permission and acknowledgment. ECJ is a registered service mark of Ervin Cohen & Jessup LLP. All rights reserved.

Subscribe

Recent Posts

Blogs

Contributors

Archives

Jump to PageX

Ervin Cohen & Jessup LLP Cookie Preference Center

Your Privacy

When you visit our website, we use cookies on your browser to collect information. The information collected might relate to you, your preferences, or your device, and is mostly used to make the site work as you expect it to and to provide a more personalized web experience. For more information about how we use Cookies, please see our Privacy Policy.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Always Active

Necessary cookies enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. These cookies may only be disabled by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how the website functions.

Functional Cookies

Always Active

Some functions of the site require remembering user choices, for example your cookie preference, or keyword search highlighting. These do not store any personal information.

Form Submissions

Always Active

When submitting your data, for example on a contact form or event registration, a cookie might be used to monitor the state of your submission across pages.

Performance Cookies

Performance cookies help us improve our website by collecting and reporting information on its usage. We access and process information from these cookies at an aggregate level.

Powered by Firmseek