
On April 29, 2025, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals revived the copyright infringement case filed by Sound and Color, LLC against Sam Smith, Normani, and related parties (collectively, “Defendants”) concerning the hit song "Dancing with a Stranger" by reversing the District Court’s granting of summary judgment in favor of Defendants. In making its decision, the Ninth Circuit affirmed the importance of the jury’s role in assessing substantial similarity.
Sound and Color initiated a copyright infringement case against Defendants based on its allegation that the chorus of Smith and Normani's "Dancing with a Stranger" infringes upon its 2015 song with the same title. The sole issue presented for summary judgment was whether the “hook” (also known as the chorus) in Sound and Color’s song is substantially similar to the hook in Defendants’ song. The District Court used the three-step analysis of the extrinsic test: (1) the plaintiff identifies similarities between the copyrighted work and accused work; (2) the Court disregards any of those similarities that are based on unprotectable material or authorized use; and (3) the Court must determine the scope of protection, either broad or thin, to which the remainder is entitled as a whole. The District Court concluded that there was no substantial similarity between the two songs’ choruses and held that the musical elements, such as pitch sequences and chord progressions, did not constitute a protectable arrangement.
In reversing the District Court’s decision, the Ninth Circuit noted that Sound and Color asserted a selection-and-arrangement theory of infringement. The selection-and-arrangement theory extends copyright protection to a combination of unprotectable elements if those elements are numerous enough and their selection and arrangement original enough that their combination constitutes an original work of authorship. A selection-and-arrangement copyright is infringed when the works share, in substantial amounts, the same combination of unprotectable elements.
The Ninth Circuit highlighted the fact that Sound and Color’s experts opined that the chorus of the two songs share the same combination of several musical elements, while Defendants emphasized some variations in the pitch sequences and chord progressions. In reversing the granting of summary judgment, the Ninth Circuit explained that the objective analysis of music under the extrinsic test does not permit a Court to simply compare the representations of pitch sequences and the visual representations of notes to determine that the two choruses are not substantially similar. The Ninth Circuit ultimately held that when there is sufficient disagreement concerning the substantial similarity of two works, the case must be submitted to a trier of fact.
KEY TAKEAWAYS:
- This decision underscores the importance of the selection-and-arrangement theory in copyright law, particularly in cases involving musical compositions. It highlights that even if individual elements are not copyrightable alone, their unique combination can warrant protection.
- Copyright holders should be cautious about moving for summary judgment on the issue of substantial similarity. If there is credible expert analysis suggesting similarity, the issue likely belongs before a jury. This can be encouraging for plaintiffs with strong but nuanced claims.
- Partner
Banu Naraghi is a Partner in the Litigation Department.
Banu’s practice focuses on corporate and intellectual property litigation in both state and federal court. She has represented a wide range of clients including content ...
Subscribe
Recent Posts
- California Supreme Court Strikes Willful Injury Limitation in BBQ Sauce Manufacturing Dispute | By: Pooja S. Nair
- Ninth Circuit Revives Copyright Suit Over Sam Smith’s “Dancing with a Stranger” and Reaffirms the Jury’s Role | By: Banu Naraghi
- Good News for Employers: Court Upholds Prospective Meal Break Waivers for Short Shifts | By: Tanner Hosfield
- Using Cal. Civ. Pro. §564(b)(9) To Get A Receiver Appointed | By: Peter A. Davidson
- FDA Announces Policy Directive Limiting Industry Representatives on Advisory Committees | By: Pooja S. Nair
- FDA and HHS to Phase Out Petroleum-Based Synthetic Dyes in Food | By: Pooja S. Nair
- FDA Webinar on the Updated Criteria for Making a “Healthy” Claim | By: Pooja S. Nair
- To Sever or Not to Sever, That is the Question For Courts Reviewing Employment Arbitration Agreements for Enforceability | By: Jared W. Slater
- Another Day, Another Dispute Between Appellate Courts Over Employment Arbitrations | By: Jared W. Slater
- The Importance of Compliance Audits Under the Amended Private Attorneys General Act | By: Jared W. Slater
Blogs
Contributors
Archives
- May 2025
- April 2025
- March 2025
- February 2025
- January 2025
- December 2024
- November 2024
- October 2024
- September 2024
- August 2024
- July 2024
- June 2024
- May 2024
- April 2024
- March 2024
- February 2024
- January 2024
- December 2023
- November 2023
- October 2023
- September 2023
- August 2023
- July 2023
- June 2023
- May 2023
- April 2023
- March 2023
- February 2023
- January 2023
- December 2022
- November 2022
- October 2022
- September 2022
- August 2022
- July 2022
- June 2022
- May 2022
- April 2022
- March 2022
- February 2022
- January 2022
- December 2021
- November 2021
- October 2021
- September 2021
- August 2021
- July 2021
- June 2021
- May 2021
- April 2021
- March 2021
- February 2021
- January 2021
- December 2020
- November 2020
- October 2020
- September 2020
- August 2020
- July 2020
- June 2020
- May 2020
- April 2020
- March 2020
- February 2020
- January 2020
- December 2019
- November 2019
- October 2019
- September 2019
- August 2019
- July 2019
- June 2019
- May 2019
- March 2019
- February 2019
- January 2019
- November 2018
- October 2018
- September 2018
- August 2018
- July 2018
- June 2018
- May 2018
- April 2018
- February 2018
- January 2018
- December 2017
- November 2017
- October 2017
- September 2017
- August 2017
- July 2017
- June 2017
- May 2017
- April 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- December 2016
- November 2016
- October 2016
- September 2016
- August 2016
- July 2016
- June 2016
- May 2016
- April 2016
- January 2016
- December 2015
- November 2015
- October 2015
- September 2015
- August 2015
- July 2015
- June 2015
- May 2015
- April 2015
- March 2015
- February 2015
- January 2015
- December 2014
- November 2014
- October 2014
- September 2014
- August 2014
- July 2014
- June 2014
- May 2014
- April 2014
- March 2014
- February 2014
- January 2014